Post Your thoughts.

Edited once, 5/8/10 - 4:36pm.

like the 2nd one best but first is good as well

Yeah same like the 2nd one better. the first one is Bright as

Edited twice, last edited 5/8/10 - 4:20pm
Reason: I FaiiL

Backgrounds are bad, looks like fall camo. Text in both are very, very average. Try adding effects and spending time on text as it makes the sig look a lot better if done properly. The renders are blended ok, but nothing spectular. Try adding some effects other then a brush and text, follow a few tutorials in the GFX section.

yeh transformers render are over used...

imo moton blur looks really bad on first one, in text and on the render.

and for next time in second one rather then just grabbing a circle brush and smudging the render away try some more scattered brushes

there ok but you need to fix my sig first! lol hurry up klegz ive only got a few days of premium left.

Reniqz you closed your shop on the day you said you were finally up to my request?

Take off the border on the text in the second one looks terrible. And the drop shadow on both.

Placement is poor, not really helping the flow

Overall text is pretty bad
.
Not quite sure what you were going for with smudging on both on them.

Again no real flow in either of them.

BG are alright but not good either. and the render as slapped on not blended.

I feel like all im doing is being mean these days *sigh*

1st. ok but text is bad. and really bright.
2nd. Render is ok and good idea wwith blending. but done poorly IMO and the BG is bad.

the sig you have now is better.

but i doesnt move...

So and this isnt about the shop its CnC stay on topic

No depth or flow.
The text is bad on both, but especially on the second one. What guesty said with using a more scattered brush would probably benefit you...