AUS/NZ
PC PS XBOX GIRL TV STORE
Login:
? Sign Up!
Powered by AMD
E-Sports Communities & Competitions

Page 2: ban national teams for competetive [LOCKED]

Started by nozl Kozzle on 2:28pm 4/1/12. 426 views and 30 posts, 0 users reading, last post by Muzza255.

Currently reading (0 users):
ban national teams
31.3%
dont ban national teams
46.9%
who cares
21.9%
Total Votes: 32   Last vote: 4:36pm 9/1/12
Poll closed: 3 months ago
Only users who have been registered for over 6 months can vote.

Prev 1 2
Joined: 20/3/11
Posts: 1,474
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Gears of War
using Safari 534.52
Rep:
35%
Just use the national teams yourself?

Go Spain.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
OP
Joined: 30/8/09
Posts: 1,401
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Black Ops
using Firefox 3.6
Rep:
52%
Quote from Trgks on the 4th of January 2012:
Quote from nozl Kozzle on the 4th of January 2012:
Quote from Trgks on the 4th of January 2012:
Quote from nozl Kozzle on the 4th of January 2012:
Quote from Trgks on the 4th of January 2012:
Quote from nozl Kozzle on the 4th of January 2012:
all national teams are just to good to be used even real madrid and barca are but f.e that there actually teams but i think we should ban the national teams.

vot in poll if agree yes to take the national teams out of fifa matches or vote no.
Dude kozzle bro you got the game like 1-2 weeks ago and you cry when ever you vs me or walsh so shut up and play the game ffs...
WTF are you on about you little chin cookiefast. i never play walsh in my life. and im not talking about versing you scronny little kunt. im saying the national teams are to good with there rating plus players in the team.

so if you gonna be a little **** dont commet.
You mad cause ur bad at fifa cause if you were good at fifa you would not have posted this shitty thread...

I rest my case

SO GO GET GOOD
im pretty sure i would have the same opinion if i was good or bad you chin.
cheers kunt!
I'm pretty sure you wouldn't because you could actually win games unlike you atm you only complain
im not complaining. just seeing if other people think the same thing as i though which is going more towards the no side which i dont mind. still got there opinions that were respectful unlike yours.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
OP
Joined: 30/8/09
Posts: 1,401
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Black Ops
using Firefox 3.6
Rep:
52%
Quote from Big Bad Reznov on the 4th of January 2012:
Just use the national teams yourself?

Go Spain.
naa dont like using them because people end up calling you shit. i go italy teams
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Joined: 20/3/11
Posts: 1,474
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Gears of War
using Safari 534.52
Rep:
35%
I understand that.

Maybe there should be separate ladders then;

Ladder 1 - National teams only (Maybe a limited amount - Germany, Spain, England, Italy, France, Netherlands).
Ladder 2 - Club teams (Maybe English Premier League only or another league or just certain clubs - Chelsea, Barca, Real Madrid, Liverpool etc.)

I know FIFA is super popular, I haven't played comp on this site yet but it should be a fairly active ladder but I don't know if it is? Depends on the admins.

edit: Yeah just looked at the rules lol Admins have done a lazy job in my opinion. Need to enforce more rules/guidelines than that, set certain boundaries to make it more competitive. Having two ladders would be ideal imo, this needs to be looked into.

Edited once, 4/1/12 - 3:35pm.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Joined: 4/6/10
Posts: 1,719
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Call of Duty
using Safari 533.19
Rep:
39%
If you cant beat em join em'.

But yehh its pre homo.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
I came, I saw, I gabbered.
OP
Joined: 30/8/09
Posts: 1,401
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Black Ops
using Firefox 3.6
Rep:
52%
Quote from Big Bad Reznov on the 4th of January 2012:
I understand that.

Maybe there should be separate ladders then;

Ladder 1 - National teams only (Maybe a limited amount - Germany, Spain, England, Italy, France, Netherlands).
Ladder 2 - Club teams (Maybe English Premier League only or another league or just certain clubs - Chelsea, Barca, Real Madrid, Liverpool etc.)

I know FIFA is super popular, I haven't played comp on this site yet but it should be a fairly active ladder but I don't know if it is? Depends on the admins.
naa dont think anyone would want to separate the national teams to the normal club teams
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Joined: 20/3/11
Posts: 1,474
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Gears of War
using Safari 534.52
Rep:
35%
Well you just answered your own question basically.

Just use the National teams..
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
OP
Joined: 30/8/09
Posts: 1,401
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Black Ops
using Firefox 3.6
Rep:
52%
Quote from Big Bad Reznov on the 4th of January 2012:
Well you just answered your own question basically.

Just use the National teams..
the poll answered my question
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Joined: 1/12/08
Posts: 7,563
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Call of Duty
using Safari 7534.48
Rep:
65%
you can only use 14 players, even if the International teams have 20+ 80+ doesn't mean its more of and advantage then using Clubs who have 15+ 80+
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
  • Additional:
  • CG Review Team
  • Premium Tag:
  • Melons are alright
BPL
Joined: 22/8/08
Posts: 4,570
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Call of Duty: MW3
using Chrome 19.0
Rep:
61%
Xbox CoD Admin
Xbox Platform Mod
I honestly don't believe that International teams as a whole are overpowered, and if we were to go down the route of banning 5 star teams, you'll be left with Napoli. Variety is reduced, the spectacle is reduced, and nobody particularly wants to play with crappy teams.

This isn't CoD where identifying an overpowered item is as simple as looking at weapon stats. In FIFA, a player using Chelsea can beat Spain, and similarly, a player using Spain can beat Chelsea. Nothing is clear-cut, team ratings and to a lesser extent player ratings are not a definitive guide, and so the trick therefore lies in having versatile tactics and being able to adapt.

For the record, you will find that most, if not all, competitive FIFA websites and competitions do not ban the use of certain teams.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
  • CG Contributions:
  • FIFA Admin
  • Xbox CoD PUG Admin
  • Xbox Media Team
  • Additional:
  • Shoutcaster
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Joined: 14/1/11
Posts: 658
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Black Ops
using Chrome 19.0
Rep:
41%
Quote from Marsh 04 on the 4th of January 2012:
madrid and man city are better then any national team
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Joined: 21/6/09
Posts: 2,282
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Black Ops
using Safari 6533.18
Rep:
50%
Xbox Referee
I don't see what the problem is.
If everyone is using a national team, how are you going to get called a pussy or whatever you said if you use them. This isn't like Forza, where an S rated car could flog a F rated car no matter how goodthe driver is. On this game a 2 star team could even beat a 5 star team if the player is good.
If you take out the National teams, people will just start using Madrid and all the good English teams and you would have the same problem again.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Joined: 1/7/10
Posts: 255
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: Modern Warfare 3
using Chrome 19.0
Rep:
28%
Quote from Marsh 04 on the 4th of January 2012:
madrid and chelsea are better then any national team
CHELSEA??? wtf FC Basel are better than them, chelsea are horrible on FIFA 12
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Im Swiss so what? Its Football not Soccer!
siv
Joined: 2/9/08
Posts: 1,922
Defaults: AU - PC:
using Chrome 19.0
Rep:
56%
Quote from BPL on the 4th of January 2012:
I honestly don't believe that International teams as a whole are overpowered, and if we were to go down the route of banning 5 star teams, you'll be left with Napoli. Variety is reduced, the spectacle is reduced, and nobody particularly wants to play with crappy teams.

This isn't CoD where identifying an overpowered item is as simple as looking at weapon stats. In FIFA, a player using Chelsea can beat Spain, and similarly, a player using Spain can beat Chelsea. Nothing is clear-cut, team ratings and to a lesser extent player ratings are not a definitive guide, and so the trick therefore lies in having versatile tactics and being able to adapt.

For the record, you will find that most, if not all, competitive FIFA websites and competitions do not ban the use of certain teams.

Pretty much this. Banning teams is illogical and unnecessary for many reasons.

@OP: This discussion pops up every year. If you want to gain further understanding as to why no teams should be banned, I recommend this thread from last year.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
Joined: 12/4/09
Posts: 370
Defaults: AU - XBOX360: FIFA
using Chrome 18.0
Rep:
55%
The rules will not be changed. Practice and internationals will not be an issue for you.

Tired of rehashing the same thread each year, if you want to know anything more read the thread siv linked.
Posted on Wednesday, 4th January 2012
 
Prev 1 2

Page 2: ban national teams for competetive [LOCKED]